Asia – indigo (Album Review)

Review of the new Asia studio album, “Indigo”, released on November 6, 2026.

by Geoff Bailie

When John Wetton passed away, it’s fair to say that the prog world united in grief at the death of a man who was both a pioneer of this genre of music, and also very under-recognized. In the nine years since then, Geoff Downes has respectfully taken small steps that have led to this new Asia album. Some live tribute shows eventually led to a key piece of the jigsaw: Harry Whitley. A relative unknown, Whitley is a multi-instrumentalist with a vocal range and style aligned with that of John Wetton. Harry dazzled everyone who saw the Wetton tribute show, which also featured guitarist John Mitchell. That line-up has now evolved into the Official Asia band, adding Virgil Donati on drums.

I’ve been impressed by how this line-up has moved from forming, to playing live shows, (including every track from the first 3 Asia albums), to now releasing this album. It feels like an appropriate evolution.

So, you’ve taken in the Roger Dean (who else?) cover, track 1 – “The Traveller (Into The Light)”. It’s definitely Asia. So please leave the “tribute band/doesn’t contain (insert name here)” comments because it’s all been said before. Just listen. It’s Asia leaning towards their heavier / proggier side. Many things strike me but a big part of this is the production and the mix. It’s got more energy and excitement than some of the reunion era albums, and that sustains throughout the record. When you hit the chorus and the stacked harmonies line up, for me, this is the (new) Asia singer doing what Asia do. If he’d had an operatic Freddie Mercury style voice or Geoff Tate roar, it just wouldn’t have been Asia. Harry wins me over on track one. Geoff’s keys are expansive, Mitchell hits a killer solo and Virgil Donati is driving this thing along! Again he’s got the Asia drum style nailed but brings much of his own flair. And I should say – this is a Whitley / Downes original, the same as most of the album!

Track 2, “Change of Heart,” this album’s “Smile Has Left Your Eyes,” is one of two songs written by Geoff Downes and his DBA partner Chris Braide. I would say that this song and the other Braide co-write, “On A Winter’s Night” are perhaps towards the poppier side of the band, which isn’t surprising with Chris Braide’s amazing pedigree. Both great songs, with repeated listenings they feel a bit like pauses in the albums dynamic and flow.

With “Arcadia” (they must have been tempted to have that as the album title??!!) it feels like we’ve kicked back in. Harry shows the breadth of his vocal capability on this one once again. I’ve often read in recent Yes album reviews how some fans feel Geoff Downes can be too low in the Yes-mix. That’s not a comment you’ll make hearing this album – the keyboard tracks here are densely layered and this track has so many keyboard sounds along with organ and piano (particularly the closing interlude). The guitar is present but, as has often been the case in Asia, it occupies a place in the mix with a lower level of prominence than the keys, but plays a vital part in the sound. This one has a nice solo piano outro. Meanwhile, “Is This The Life?” has another killer chorus, a Downes/ Whitley/ Mitchell composition and a great example of what this new Asia are capable of – and a superb guitar solo!

If “Tattoo Indigo” was a single 11 minute track, it would be the longest in the Asia catalogue… but the 3 part split means it doesn’t quite grab that title. It’s the absolute highlight of this album for me. Part 1 conjures memories of the original self-titled debut album – hints of all sorts of call backs, including a section that reminds me of Yes’s “Machine Messiah”. The Downes/ Whitley instrumental showcases all of the band, and leads into the acoustic opening of Part 2 – a brief 2 minute melodic idea which came in part from John Wetton. Part 3 brings us back to the themes and progginess of Part 1, returning to the melody from Part 2, as Whitley jumps an octave. If you want to make your own playlist, you could swap this Part 3 out with the bonus track version which features Mike Portnoy on drums! It’s a cool variation, with some vocoder vocals replacing what was in the other version. It’s completely right that this track gives the album its title because it’s certainly the standout! And for any keyboard warriors who might get agitated that “this line up isn’t Asia”, check this one out, and then send me your apology!

“Live In The Sun” and “Hymn For The Fallen,” while both being good songs, feel a bit in the shadow of the epic track and it takes “Night and Day” for the album to kick into gear again. This is a track that, for me, would fit seamlessly into the Astra era, and, as that was my first Asia album, it’s a big compliment! “Valencia (The Ghost Ship)/ An Elegy” is a pretty lightweight track, similar in style to Valkyrie from the Gravitas.

By contrast “Chesapeake Bay” is another standout. Steve Howe joins on some slide dobro, with Geoff Downes on piano, and heavily reverbed vocals from Harry. Stripped of some of the pomp and layers present in previous tracks, I understand this was an unfinished Wetton/ Downes track that Harry helped to complete, and I’m delighted they did.

The closing track of the album “Echo of You” is a song of loss. It feels like a poignant way to end the album, and has some cool almost counterpoint vocals and a really excellent John Mitchell solo in the mix – Virgil even gets a chance to let loose a bit!

If I had to offer any critique on Indigo, it would be that it left me wondering whether less could be more, if it had been trimmed to a 45/50 minute recording? That aside, the return of Asia is something to be celebrated by anyone who has been a fan of the band – and the main reason for that is because lightning has struck twice!!! The new line-up brings fresh ideas and a set of strong tracks, presented in a way that honors the band’s legacy. I hope we hear more from this Asia soon!

Order here: https://ffm.bio/asia-indigo

“Indigo” Tracklist:

The Traveller (Into The Light)
Change Of Heart
Arcadia
Is This The Life?
Tattoo Indigo (Part 1)
Tattoo Indigo (Part 2)
Tattoo Indigo (Part 3)
Life In The Sun
Hymn For The Fallen
Night And Day
Valencia (The Ghost Ship)
An Elegy
Chesapeake Bay (Featuring Steve Howe)
On A Winters Night
Echo Of You
Line Up:

Geoff Downes
Virgil Donati
John Mitchell
Harry Whitley

Support The Prog Report

If you like what we do please support us on Ko-fi




Podcast




Subscribe to our email list: